There's a difference between not knowing and pretending to know. One builds credibility. The other destroys it. Not knowing vs. fake knowing Not knowing vs. fake knowing Not knowing is a temporary state. It's the honest admission that you lack information, experience, or understanding about something specific. It's uncomfortable but actionable—you can learn, research, ask questions, or find someone who does know. Fake knowing is a permanent trap. It's the performance of expertise you don't possess, driven by ego, insecurity, or the misguided belief that admitting ignorance is weakness. Once you fake it, you stop learning. You become invested in defending a position rather than discovering the truth. The CEO who says "I don't understand the technical details, but here's what I need to know" gains respect and gets better decisions. The CEO who nods along in technical meetings while secretly lost makes worse decisions and loses credibility when the truth emerges. The compound cost of certainty theater The compound cost of certainty theater Most professionals are terrified of saying "I don't know." They've been conditioned to believe that expertise means having all the answers, that leadership requires omniscience, that credibility depends on never appearing uncertain. But this creates a perverse incentive: the more senior you become, the more dangerous it becomes to admit what you don't know. the more senior you become, the more dangerous it becomes to admit what you don't know. So instead, we perform certainty. We speak with confidence about things we're guessing at. We make decisions based on incomplete information while pretending the information is complete. We become actors in our own expertise theater. The result? Compound ignorance. Each fake-knowing moment builds on the last, creating elaborate houses of cards that eventually collapse under the weight of reality. The strategic power of intellectual humility The strategic power of intellectual humility The most effective people I know have mastered a counterintuitive skill: they're confident in their ability to figure things out, not in already having figured everything out. they're confident in their ability to figure things out, not in already having figured everything out. They distinguish between core competencies (where they should know) and adjacent areas (where not knowing is acceptable, even expected). They're quick to say "I don't know, but I know who does" or "I don't know, but here's how I'd find out." This isn't weakness—it's strategic resource allocation. Every moment spent pretending to know something you don't is a moment not spent learning something you could. The not-knowing advantage The not-knowing advantage When you're genuinely comfortable with not knowing: You ask better questions. Instead of asking questions designed to make you look smart, you ask questions designed to make you actually smart. You ask better questions. You attract better information. People share more openly with someone who admits gaps than someone who pretends to have none. You attract better information. You make faster progress. You skip the performance and go straight to the learning. You make faster progress. You build real credibility. Nothing signals competence like knowing the boundaries of your competence. You build real credibility. The admission that unlocks everything The admission that unlocks everything The phrase that changes everything isn't "I know" or "I think" or "In my experience." It's: "I don't know. Help me understand." "I don't know. Help me understand." This simple admission does three things simultaneously: it stops the pretense, starts the learning, and signals to others that you're someone worth teaching. The person who says this in a meeting doesn't look incompetent—they look like someone who prioritizes truth over ego, results over appearance, growth over stagnation. The knowing game The knowing game Here's what separates the truly capable from the merely confident: they've learned to be comfortable being wrong, uncertain, and incomplete. They know that not knowing is temporary. Fake knowing is permanent. The smartest thing you can do is admit what you don't know. The stupidest thing you can do is pretend that you do. Thank you for reading, Scott You’ve read the free edition of Scott’s Newsletter. For more insights, including weekly deep dives, powerful ideas & proven strategies from my work with some of the world's most successful people, click here to become a paid subscriber. You’ve read the free edition of Scott’s Newsletter. For more insights, including weekly deep dives, powerful ideas & proven strategies from my work with some of the world's most successful people, click here to become a paid subscriber. click here Subscribe now Subscribe now

The is an opinion piece based on the author’s POV and does not necessarily reflect the views of HackerNoon.

Every

The Comfort Trap

This Is Dangerous Advice

Connect With Scott

Read My Stories

Portfolio

Newsletter

Nominated for 2022 - Most Valuable Marketer

Nominated for 2022 - Startup Blogger of the Year

Nominated for 2022 - HackerNoon Contributor of the Year - Entrepreneurship

Nominated for 2022 - HackerNoon Contributor of the Year - Business

Nominated for 2022 - HackerNoon Contributor of the Year - Business Strategy

Nominated for 2022 - HackerNoon Contributor of the Year - Sales

Too Long; Didn't Read

Make resilience your competitive advantage

Stop Pretending You Know Everything

Stop Pretending You Know Everything

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

Untitled Story

What Is the Advice Trap and How Do You Avoid It?

Understanding How Bias Affects the Mediocrity Cycle

A Good Story Is the Difference Between Success and Survival

10x10: Ten Life Lessons from a Developer After Ten Years in the Industry

10 Ways to Prevent Burnout While Working From Home

What Is the Advice Trap and How Do You Avoid It?

Understanding How Bias Affects the Mediocrity Cycle

A Good Story Is the Difference Between Success and Survival

10x10: Ten Life Lessons from a Developer After Ten Years in the Industry

10 Ways to Prevent Burnout While Working From Home

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps