I’ve been on something of an emulation kick as of late. Maybe it’s due to all the recent delays in game releases, or perhaps the state of AAA gaming has me longing for a bygone time. Honestly, I don’t know why I have spent so much time revisiting older games and consoles; what I do know is that there was never a better time for horror games than the PS2 era.
This was an era in which graphical fidelity would skyrocket, creating far more frightening and believable worlds. Developers finally got the hang of how third-person games should play, and some of the most compelling stories in gaming were explicitly written for horror games.
It’s time to dust off the old PS2 and revisit what I consider to be the 10 best PS2 horror games of all time.
Developed by Surreal Studios, The Suffering excellently reflects its developer’s namesake, surreal. This game follows Torque, a man imprisoned for killing his family, as he fights through hordes of delightful grotesque monsters inside a penitentiary with a more action-oriented horror experience.
Creature designs are uniquely grotesque, as you fight ghosts of former prisoners still mangled and in their forms of execution. With a heavy atmosphere and an interesting morality system that influences which ending you get, The Suffering is nothing short of a fun ride.
The Clock Tower games are horror classics that, unfortunately, are yet to be resurrected from their digital graves. Clock Tower 3, released by Capcom in 2002 in Japan, was the final game in the series and, in my opinion, is the best of the three.
Clock Tower 3 has a strong, well-written story and an excellent directorial style. The whole game captures an eerie Victorian-era England horror, reminiscent of horror classics like Frankenstein and Dracula but in a more modern setting. Clock Tower 3 is a little rough around the edges, especially in 2022, but definitely worth checking out if you’re a horror game fan.
One of the most celebrated development studios around today, FromSoftware, once tried their hand at the horror genre. Inspired by Japanese kaidan ghost stories, Kuon creates a dreamlike and creepy atmosphere within its haunted manor setting. What makes Kuon particularly interesting is its excellent art style and Japanese feudal setting.
Kuon is a challenging game to track down these days but well worth the effort to find, especially if a medieval Japanese horror setting sounds interesting to you.
Siren, developed by the now-disbanded Japan Studio, follows the story of 10 survivors as they unravel the secrets of a rural Japanese town in the wake of a supernatural calamity. The story is told out of chronological order, which is refreshing and not very widespread in the gaming world. Siren also mixes themes of Christianity with Shinto to create a religious horror narrative.
Siren had a few sequels that were much better received by critics than the original. Still, to me, the first game will always be the one that left the best impression.
While narratively it isn’t as airtight as Silent Hill 2, SH3 is still a home run hit from when Team Silent was at the top of their game. Team Silent loved gathering inspiration from works outside of video games and incorporating those works into their stories. Silent Hill 3 very much feels like a surreal and tortured Brothers Grimm story about adolescence.
Silent Hill 3 builds an omnipresent sense of doom throughout the entirety of its playtime. A constant foreboding shadow is only enhanced by having some of the best graphical and design work of the time. The early to mid-2000s work by Team Silent places them high on the list of best PS2 horror games.
Haunting Ground is considered by many as a spiritual successor to the Clock Tower games, even if Capcom has never explicitly stated as much. What Haunting Ground accomplishes is a refinement of the Clock Tower formula with even better visuals and enhanced gameplay.
Much like Clock Tower, Haunting Ground follows a young woman named Fiona as she navigates an old castle. Except in this game, our main character is accompanied by a friendly white shepherd named Hewie. One of the stand out features of Haunting Ground is its excellent use of sound. Enemies can hear Fiona walk, among other sounds, creating tense moments of horror throughout the game. If you still have a PS3, you can boot it up and find Haunting Ground on the PlayStation Store. It’s definitely worth a playthrough.
Fatal Frame is arguably one of the most important games on this list. After all, where would the found footage-style gameplay of modern horror games like Outlast be without Fatal Frame laying down the foundations back in 2001?
Instead of the classic survival horror tropes of zombie shooting and evasion, Fatal Frame uses its camera obscura mechanic to make you face your terrors. Many still find Fatal Frame to be quite scary, and just from the opening mission, you can see why. It always feels like someone is watching you in this game, and the only way to find out is to turn around or perish.
Resident Evil 4 was a complete game-changer in the survival horror genre. By simply putting the camera behind the main character and translating those clunky tank controls to a new perspective, the future of survival horror would change forever.
Resident Evil 4 is all about Leon Kennedy, former Racoon City Police rookie turned secret service agent, on the hunt for the president’s daughter. While more action-focused than previous entries in the series, Resident Evil 4 is still full of plenty of scares and the visually disturbing Las Plagas monstrosities. Check out our complete timeline of the Resident Evil games to learn more.
Rule of Rose is an often overlooked horror game, mainly because it was banned in many countries. It is a very shocking game that unfortunately got caught in the crossfire of the moral panic surrounding video games in the 2000s. That said, Rule of Rose does dive into some very uncomfortable topics, including child abuse and neglect, and is exceedingly somber from start to finish.
However, Rule of Rose is still an artistically significant game that was not afraid of making the player uncomfortable by presenting the horrors of the real world in a video game. Art that makes you feel something, be it joy or disgust, is always worth discussing.
It wouldn’t be a list of the best PS2 horror games without it. What is there to say about Silent Hill 2 that hasn’t been said already?
It has a deep story based on Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment. Our main character, James, is haunted by his actions in the past and is seeking redemption. There are characters and enemies that thematically fit James’ state of mind, causing him to battle his demons physically and metaphorically.
Everything about Silent Hill 2 is intentional. Expertly weaving its themes into both gameplay and story, which is a challenging feat for video games. There are always small bits about Silent Hill 2 that you can go back and discover. It’s like when you finish a book for the first time and then reread it, and it’s better the second time, thanks to your existing knowledge of events. Silent Hill 2 is definitely a can’t-miss PlayStation 2 game.
The PS2 was an excellent time for horror game fans. This era set the foundations for just about every horror game we see in the market today. Luckily, many game directors and studios of this time are still in the industry today. Shinji Mikami of Resident Evil fame is working on the upcoming GhostWire: Tokyo and has directed the excellent Evil Within games. FromSoftware created the groundbreaking Bloodborne, crossing horror aesthetics with Soulslike combat. Hopefully, Konami gets its act together and revives Fatal Frame and Silent Hill, among other great IPs that they own.
Some of the best PS2 horror games still hold up against even modern horror classics that are backed with bigger budgets and higher production value. Whether through emulation or cracking open that old PS2 again, it is always a good time to go back and relive the golden age of PlayStation horror games.
More in Gaming: