Apple's about changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store in the European Union reads with the professionalism and poise of a teenager throwing a tantrum. It's amazing really. press release Some choice quotes, emphasis mine: Across every change, Apple is introducing new safeguards that reduce — but don’t eliminate — to EU users. new risks the DMA poses Apple will share new resources to help EU users understand the changes they can expect. That includes guidance to help EU users — including a less intuitive user experience — and best practices for approaching new risks associated with downloading apps and processing payments outside of the App Store. navigate complexities the DMA’s changes bring Inevitably, the new options for developers’ EU apps . Apple can’t eliminate those risks, but within the DMA’s constraints, the company will take steps to reduce them. create new risks to Apple users and their devices And possibly my favorite quote from this whole article: EU users will be with a list of default browsers before they have the opportunity to understand the options available to them. The screen also EU users’ experience the first time they open Safari intending to navigate to a webpage. confronted interrupts That's a hell of a way to say that EU users will be asked to choose their favorite browser! With their announcements yesterday, Apple is indicating that they don't intend to comply with the Digital Markets Act after all, an unsurprising move to be sure. I have no doubt that Apple's legions of lawyers know that their new strategy is blatantly illegal, so they must be gearing up for years of court battles to delay the inevitable as long as they can instead. The DMA has many clauses that specify that gatekeepers must ensure alternative platforms have " " interoperability, which is certainly not the case here: free of charge iOS apps distributed from the App Store and/or an alternative app marketplace will pay €0.50 for each first annual install per year over a 1 million threshold. For an app like Instagram, that could be nearly $11,000,000 for the privilege of using Apple's App Store. per month not And, if you still want to open an alternative marketplace anyway, you ... must Provide Apple a stand-by letter of credit from an A-rated (or equivalent by S&P, Fitch, or Moody’s) financial Institution of €1,000,000 to establish adequate financial means in order to guarantee support for your developers and users. I think anyone who was hoping for iOS's alternative is thoroughly disappointed today. Big Tech companies flouting the law is, of course, nothing new, but the EU should nip this in the bud before it gets out of hand. F-Droid The Illusion of Choice All of this being said, the DMA does have legitimate issues, which I don't think enough people are talking about either. Regulators, Apple, and tech commenters seem to be falsely equating the existence of alternative app stores with an open market. In reality, individual users will have no more real choices on iOS than they had before, even if the EU gets its way. The road that Apple is heading down—one which actually allowed by the DMA—looks something like this: Apps will be distributed on the App Store via an alternative publisher. This isn't a real choice; you will just end up juggling multiple app stores. is or If this problem isn't addressed, we're just replacing one walled garden with many walled gardens, and people will have to participate in each one to keep the same experience they had before. We've seen this play out in the movie and television industry already with the proliferation of streaming services created by distributors. I don't think any consumer on Earth would argue that the state of streaming platforms today is what an ideal marketplace should look like, and indeed, digital as a result. piracy is on the rise again The music industry provides an example of the alternative to this model, one which many customers enjoy today. Music streaming platforms offer true marketplaces that people can choose between, whether it's Spotify, Apple Music, TIDAL, or one of many others, which all largely share a similar catalog. There are some minor differences, sure, but consumers largely choose between these platforms based on features and pricing, not content availability. This model drives competition and offers a far more open ecosystem overall. Neither Apple developers like Epic Games seem too keen to adopt this option. real nor Maybe we will eventually find a middle ground where apps are published to Apple's App Store alternatives, and consumers can choose between marketplaces based on factors like pricing and features rather than exclusive content. That future doesn't seem likely to me at the moment. and Time will tell whether the EU will react to all of this and how the digital apps marketplace situation will play out overall, but one thing is clear to me: Consumers—EU or otherwise—aren't really winning yet. Also published . here

The is an opinion piece based on the author’s POV and does not necessarily reflect the views of HackerNoon.

Apple's iOS 17.2 Update Brings a Much-Needed Security Improvement to iMessage

Visit my Homepage

Newsletter

Too Long; Didn't Read

Boost your HackerNoon story @ $159.99! 🚀

Apple is Furious About the Digital Markets Act

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

Untitled Story

Apple's iOS 17.2 Update Brings a Much-Needed Security Improvement to iMessage

10 Soul-Crushing Reasons to Abandon the Catastrophic Mess That Is Swift

10 Best Free Vector Icon Resources for App Design & Web Design in 2018

The Noonification: Innovation Is Slowing Down (10/19/2022)

The Noonification: 2024 Just Might Be The Year Crypto Enthusiasts Are Looking For (1/8/2024)

Apple's iOS 17.2 Update Brings a Much-Needed Security Improvement to iMessage

10 Soul-Crushing Reasons to Abandon the Catastrophic Mess That Is Swift

10 Best Free Vector Icon Resources for App Design & Web Design in 2018

The Noonification: Innovation Is Slowing Down (10/19/2022)

The Noonification: 2024 Just Might Be The Year Crypto Enthusiasts Are Looking For (1/8/2024)

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps