What are PR’s, how to effectively create a PR, how to give feedback on PR’s and how to respond to feedback What is a Pull Request (PR)? It is a request for changing code in a repository. Once you make changes you need in your code, you submit a PR. Once submitted, interested parties will perform a code review and provide you with any feedback/changes needed. Pull Requests are typically used by teams The idea is to make sure well written and bug-free code gets pushed to the repository. It is a way to develop high-quality code. for shared collaboration and feature work or bug fixes. How to Create a Pull Request Breakdown your story/feature Before you start working on a story/feature, This doesn’t just help your reviewer but also as you can keep track of your progress and get frequent feedback. Another benefit is, as the codebase is shared with other developers, reverting a change gets a lot easier. Hence, try to keep the scope of your PR to a single issue while breaking it down. make a mental/written note on how you want to break it down into several smaller PR’s. YOU For example, let’s say you are implementing a todo list and have the following story: As a user, I can add and delete items to/from a list respectively I would break it down by: Add a text box and an add button on the page. Clicking on add button adds the item to the list Clicking on delete button on the list item deletes that item from the list PR #1: PR #2: PR #3: You will get reviewer blessings 🙏 for doing so. Imagine if your co-worker blasted a HUGE PR, you wouldn’t want to review, would you? 🙈 Add comments on your PR How to add a code comment Wherever you have done something different, usually, it’s a good idea to 🔗 explaining why you did what you did. If you are not completely sure of your code, you should definitely tag “@” at those who have the most context on that code to get some feedback. For example, add a comment on the line number You used a new function from the library called which might not be used in the codebase a lot, you might want to add a comment there saying . L[odash](https://lodash.com/docs/4.17.10) isNan this function basically checks if the value is Nan and returns a boolean This helps your reviewer a lot as that saves their time (i.e. if they don’t already know what the function does). Add screenshots/gifs Screenshots and gifs are proof that the code that you submitted works! A screenshot definitely works although when your code is doing more than what a screenshot can capture, create a gif. By using a gif, you can click around and show everything that your PR covers. My favourite one is: 🔗 This increases the likelihood of acceptance and also gives your reviewer a visual of what you have implemented. Licecap Tests are documentation of your code Whenever you have worked on something which makes sense to you and you want to explain this complex code to developers your intention for that particular change. Don’t litter the code with code comments and ask yourself these questions, if it’s so difficult to understand, future Can I split this code into smaller functions? Can I rename this function to something more obvious? ask your team for function name suggestions if you like. How can I simplify my code further so I don’t call it complex? Irrespective of what you pick, you should write a TEST. 🔥 Try to add a test explaining that part of your code. Your tests are there to test your logic but also, are the documentation of your code. How to review Pull Requests? Be empathetic As a reviewer, it’s extremely important to provide feedback in a courteous manner. that you are reviewing your teammates’ code who you like to talk to and go for team outings, lunches etc. Hence, be more empathetic during your reviews. You need to remember They are human, they have feelings and feelings can get hurt easily! 💥 Make yourself more familiar with the code Always get in the habit of teaching and it doesn’t matter if you consider yourself a junior or a senior developer. Instead of telling them what the problem is, ask them questions, and use a friendly tone. Following are a few examples: make them think maybe we could assign this to a variable and re-use it on line 9? Do you think possibly use this helpful utility that already does that for us which our dear teammate Sarah built? Could we move this code in its own function so we can write more tests 😃? Can we this option 🤔? What do you think about trying This will make them possibly think that the function name could be renamed. After they explain what it does, then follow it up with a suggestion such as: I’m not sure if I understand the whole picture but could you explain what this function is doing? “I get it now, sorry for being slow! I’m not sure but do you think we could rename this function to option1, option2 or something along those lines, what are your thoughts”? as remember you are a reviewer and they wrote the code so its possible they have more context than you do. Always ask them their thoughts Imagine if your co-worker used words such as “Don’t do this, just rename the function”. That sounds so much direct, less friendly and sounds like you are giving them a command rather than taking their input on it. Always provide suggestions for code improvements Rather than just telling them, “this code could be improved”. Provide them suggestions/examples on how it could be improved further for example, This code works perfectly but after I started reading it further, I thought of another idea that I wanted to run it by you. I’m not sure but what about? sample code #1, sample code #2What are your thoughts? Use emoji’s Online criticism is misinterpreted easily. Hence, emoji’s are one of the best for communicating online. Using them automatically adds a friendly tone to your sentences. But if that’s not you then don’t force it, keep it real. tool Use it when you start feeling that the conversation is getting too serious . Take it offline If you find yourself going back and forth in conversations with your teammate, the conversations are getting too long and its leading nowhere, take it offline. There is no point spending time typing when you can quickly hop on a call 🤙or just walk 🚶‍ to their desk. . When you come to a conclusion, post a comment on the PR summarizing your discussion so other readers following along are aware of it and When you meet face to face, you automatically develop more empathy and understand their point of view even further and alternatively, they understand yours your future self will thank you for it. nitpick While reviewing code, you may find something that is basically a nitpick i.e. it may not necessarily block the approval of the PR but something to consider. They can be related to grammar corrections, un-intentional new lines, any aesthetics, minor code refactor etc. For example, Nitpicks are not important but technically correct. nit: extra white spacenit: can we assign this value to a `constant` for better readability purposes? How to respond to feedback The rules that apply while submitting a PR equally apply while responding to it as well. When suggestions are provided Always remember that you are collaborating and writing code. If a suggestion is provided, always treat it . If you don’t understand something, ask for clarification for example, like a possibility of improving your code “Can you please provide an example or Can you please clarify further? I don’t understand it completely.” If you think the feedback is valid, implement it! However big or small the change is, if you think the feedback is valid, always reply and let the reviewer know that you took their feedback. For example, That’s an excellent point, change coming right away! Good point, thanks for catching that. If you disagree 👈 Disagreements are bound to happen as different developers have different ways of writing code. Although, try to voice your opinion in a very friendly manner. For example, If you agree to them partially then let them know but also provide your reasoning at where you disagree with them. That’s a great point. I do agree with your first suggestion, will make a change right away. Totally missed that one. Although for the 2nd one, I did consider that option and decided to not go that route as for the following scenario, we don’t want to display that. // or whatever your reasoning was, be honest. 👈 Make your commit message obvious Gitmoji — commits example Now that you spent time on your feedback, write a good commit message which lets the reviewer know that you did consider their feedback but don’t make the message too long. A very handy tool is 🔗 i. 😍 They provide an easy way of identifying the purpose or intention of a commit by looking at the emojis used. Gitmoj Take it a step further You have made some changes in your code based on the feedback you got. Now your code handles an additional scenario which you didn’t think of or wasn’t aware or may have missed but there’s your chance to . “Write a test” Once your code is merged in, a defect gets filled. to make sure that the defect is actually fixed and there’s proof 🕵️‍. Now, its documented!! 😃 You get brownie 🍫 points if you take it a step further. You will automatically gain the trust of your team.f Once you fix that defect, add a test I hope you enjoyed reading this article and learned something. If you did, please give it a 👏 and also, share your personal experience on pull requests in comments. If you have any questions, please feel free to reach out on my Twitter.

Twitter

Too Long; Didn't Read

In your car, at home, or at work — Bosch technology shapes many areas of life.

The Art of Humanizing Pull Requests (PR’s)

Too Long; Didn't Read

Companies Mentioned

Ankita Kulkarni

About Author

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN...

The Art of Humanizing Pull Requests (PR’s)

Too Long; Didn't Read

Companies Mentioned

Ankita Kulkarni

About Author

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN...

RELATED STORIES