How much social media content is created by real people, as opposed to bots or duplicate accounts? This is a problem that has persisted throughout the internet since its inception, but one that has gotten much worse in recent years with – people who run vast quantities of accounts as a means of providing paid interactions within a network. the prevalence of click-farms This issue has gained more traction in recent weeks, with Elon Musk currently raising concerns as he attempts to buy Twitter. His was partially based on Twitter's claim that of monetized daily active users (mDAUs) are fake, but has since placed his bid on hold as the Twitter CEO, Parag Agrawal, has of this estimation. initial bid of $44 billion less than 5% failed to show proof The Battle Against Bots and click-farms Elon Musk’s concerns regarding fake activity are not new. While Twitter has measures in place to locate and shut down bot accounts, such as using CAPTCHAs, click-farm-runners can complete multiple of these with ease as . Twitter also monitors IP addresses and blocks accounts that are attached to the same ones, but click-farmers are able to obfuscate and change their addresses, so this only slows them down. Stoping click-farms altogether is not easy – one approach could be for Twitter to implement a KYC (know your customer) system where people must provide sensitive documents to get verified, but click-farms can simply buy accounts off users who already have completed KYC. they are not bots but rather humans running 100s of accounts Currently, Elon Musk’s worries about the prevalence of fake accounts have placed Twitter at a standstill, as its executives are yet to produce the number or percentage of bots occupying their network. This has led people to question whether they know , ideally via the scientific method – as Elon Musk has been . Identifying real people on the internet and gathering the results in a scientific way is admittedly tough, but it is far from impossible. how to suitably provide such proof asking for in interviews Andrew Edi, the co-founder of , a blockchain, has created a model for measuring the number of bots or duplicate accounts on Twitter. Better still, this model (such as photos, ID, videos, or other documents), making this a non-invasive method that preserves the privacy of each user. Let’s delve into how this model works. Idena proof-of-person does not use any identifying information Finding a Ratio of Live and Real Users To gain an estimate of real Twitter users, Edi proposes that Twitter run a set of trials. On random days, at random times, a random selection of Twitter users who are actively using the platform will be counted. This can easily be done by checking whether an account is posting, scrolling on their feed, using the search bar, or performing essentially any other activity at the selected time. Once these users have been chosen, Twitter will then present them with This will be a simple test that is designed to be easy for humans, and practically impossible for machines to pass. But perhaps most importantly, this test cannot be completed by one person running more than one account at a time, making it resistant to click-farms. It is called a Filter for Live Intelligent People (or FLIP) test. a test, all at the same time, with a time limit for solving. CAPTCHA-style If a user passes this test, then they will be considered a genuine and real person. This will allow us to make a of the ratio of real/fake users, providing a clearer picture of what Twitter’s ecosystem really looks like. statistical estimate What is a FLIP Test? At the heart of this method is the FLIP test, which is a . Users are given two sets of images and are asked to choose which image tells a story. These images contain no text or numbers, making them perfect for people who speak any language and can be completed regardless of a person’s educational background. simple picture-based task The reason FLIPs are able to stop click-farms is that, while they are easy for humans, they require some level of concentration, and because these tests would be deployed , it means that click-farmers cannot simply complete them on one device and then go to the next as it will take too long. Although FLIPs are not hard, they do take a little bit of time to evaluate the images being shown, which is important for weeding out duplicate accounts. all at the same time What Would We Learn? This proposed model would help Twitter to evaluate fake activity. It would give an indication of , as opposed to bots, duplicate accounts, and clickfarms. It would not test how many inauthentic accounts have ever been created on Twitter, but rather how many are currently in use, which would give a strong indication of the ratio of real-to-fake users on the platform. how many real people are actively using Twitter Whether Elon Musk or Twitter’s CEO would be happy with the results they find is a different story altogether. The topic of how many phony users occupy the Twitter space is a contentious one, but . This model is a step towards finding clarity on Twitter, and if it works then it can be easily applied to practically any other social media platform. until a proper test is run, nobody truly knows just how bad (or good) the situation is Read the full method for . measuring real users here

Twitter

YouTube

Eliminating Polarization in Web3

Understanding Idena – The Human-Centric Blockchain

Nominated for 2022 - HackerNoon Contributor of the Year - Cybersecurity

Nominated for 2022 - HackerNoon Contributor of the Year - Elon Musk

Nominated for 2022 - HackerNoon Contributor of the Year - Social Media

Too Long; Didn't Read

CTA: Download the FREE AI Productivity Shift report

How Twitter Can Satisfy Elon Musk's Request for Fake Account Clarity

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

Untitled Story

Eliminating Polarization in Web3

Windows Sticky Keys Exploit: The War Veteran That Never Dies

06/02/2018: Biggest Stories in the Cryptosphere

0-Days are on the Rise and that Means a Lot More Work for SOC Teams

Time Bombs Inside Software: 0-Day Log4Shell is Just the Tip of The Iceberg

Eliminating Polarization in Web3

Windows Sticky Keys Exploit: The War Veteran That Never Dies

06/02/2018: Biggest Stories in the Cryptosphere

0-Days are on the Rise and that Means a Lot More Work for SOC Teams

Time Bombs Inside Software: 0-Day Log4Shell is Just the Tip of The Iceberg

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps