When building data indexing pipelines, handling large files efficiently presents unique challenges. For example, patent XML files from the USPTO can contain hundreds of patents in a single file, with each file being over 1GB in size. Processing such large files requires careful consideration of processing granularity and resource management. In this article we will discuss the best practices of processing large files in data indexing systems for AI use cases, like RAG or semantic search. Understanding Processing Granularity Processing granularity determines when and how frequently we commit processed data to storage. This seemingly simple decision has significant implications for system reliability, resource utilization, and recovery capabilities. The Trade-offs of Commit Frequency While committing after every small operation provides maximum recoverability, it comes with substantial costs: Frequent database writes are expensive
Complex logic needed to track partial progress
Performance overhead from constant state synchronization Frequent database writes are expensive Complex logic needed to track partial progress Performance overhead from constant state synchronization On the other hand, processing entire large files before committing can lead to: High memory pressure
Long periods without checkpoints
Risk of losing significant work on failure High memory pressure Long periods without checkpoints Risk of losing significant work on failure Finding the Right Balance A reasonable processing granularity typically lies between these extremes. The default approach is to: Process each source entry independently
Batch commit related entries together
Maintain trackable progress without excessive overhead Process each source entry independently Batch commit related entries together Maintain trackable progress without excessive overhead Challenging Scenarios 1. Non-Independent Sources (Fan-in) The default granularity breaks down when source entries are interdependent: Join operations between multiple sources
Grouping related entries
Clustering that spans multiple entries
Intersection calculations across sources Join operations between multiple sources Grouping related entries Clustering that spans multiple entries Intersection calculations across sources After fan-in operations like grouping or joining, we need to establish new processing units at the appropriate granularity - for example, at the group level or post-join entity level. 2. Fan-out with Heavy Processing When a single source entry fans out into many derived entries, we face additional challenges: Light Fan-out Light Fan-out Breaking an article into chunks
Many small derived entries
Manageable memory and processing requirements Breaking an article into chunks Many small derived entries Manageable memory and processing requirements Heavy Fan-out Heavy Fan-out Large source files (e.g., 1GB USPTO XML)
Thousands of derived entries
Computationally intensive processing
High memory multiplication factor Large source files (e.g., 1GB USPTO XML) Thousands of derived entries Computationally intensive processing High memory multiplication factor The risks of processing at full file granularity include: Memory Pressure: Processing memory requirements can be N times the input size
Long Checkpoint Intervals: Extended periods without commit points
Recovery Challenges: Failed jobs require full recomputation
Completion Risk: In cloud environments with worker restarts:

If processing takes 24 hours but workers restart every 8 hours
Job may never complete due to frequent interruptions
Resource priority changes can affect stability Memory Pressure: Processing memory requirements can be N times the input size Memory Pressure Long Checkpoint Intervals: Extended periods without commit points Long Checkpoint Intervals Recovery Challenges: Failed jobs require full recomputation Recovery Challenges Completion Risk: In cloud environments with worker restarts:

If processing takes 24 hours but workers restart every 8 hours
Job may never complete due to frequent interruptions
Resource priority changes can affect stability Completion Risk If processing takes 24 hours but workers restart every 8 hours
Job may never complete due to frequent interruptions
Resource priority changes can affect stability If processing takes 24 hours but workers restart every 8 hours Job may never complete due to frequent interruptions Resource priority changes can affect stability Best Practices for Large File Processing 1. Adaptive Granularity After fan-out operations, establish new smaller granularity units for downstream processing: Break large files into manageable chunks
Process and commit at chunk level
Maintain progress tracking per chunk Break large files into manageable chunks Process and commit at chunk level Maintain progress tracking per chunk 2. Resource-Aware Processing Consider available resources when determining processing units: Memory constraints
Processing time limits
Worker stability characteristics
Recovery requirements Memory constraints Processing time limits Worker stability characteristics Recovery requirements 3. Balanced Checkpointing Implement checkpointing strategy that balances: Recovery capability
Processing efficiency
Resource utilization
System reliability Recovery capability Processing efficiency Resource utilization System reliability How CocoIndex Helps CocoIndex provides built-in support for handling large file processing: CocoIndex Smart Chunking

Automatic chunk size optimization
Memory-aware processing
Efficient progress tracking


Flexible Granularity

Configurable processing units
Adaptive commit strategies
Resource-based optimization


Reliable Processing

Robust checkpoint management
Efficient recovery mechanisms
Progress persistence Smart Chunking

Automatic chunk size optimization
Memory-aware processing
Efficient progress tracking Smart Chunking Automatic chunk size optimization
Memory-aware processing
Efficient progress tracking Automatic chunk size optimization Memory-aware processing Efficient progress tracking Flexible Granularity

Configurable processing units
Adaptive commit strategies
Resource-based optimization Flexible Granularity Configurable processing units
Adaptive commit strategies
Resource-based optimization Configurable processing units Adaptive commit strategies Resource-based optimization Reliable Processing

Robust checkpoint management
Efficient recovery mechanisms
Progress persistence Reliable Processing Robust checkpoint management
Efficient recovery mechanisms
Progress persistence Robust checkpoint management Efficient recovery mechanisms Progress persistence By handling these complexities automatically, CocoIndex allows developers to focus on their transformation logic while ensuring reliable and efficient processing of large files. Conclusion Processing large files in indexing pipelines requires careful consideration of granularity, resource management, and reliability. Understanding these challenges and implementing appropriate strategies is crucial for building robust indexing systems. CocoIndex provides the tools and framework to handle these complexities effectively, enabling developers to build reliable and efficient large-scale indexing pipelines. CocoIndex It would mean a lot to us if you could support Cocoindex on Github with a star if you like our work. Thank you so much with a warm coconut hug 🥥🤗. It would mean a lot to us if you could support Cocoindex on Github with a star if you like our work. Thank you so much with a warm coconut hug 🥥🤗. support Cocoindex on Github with a star Cocoindex on Github

This story contains new, firsthand information uncovered by the writer.

Data Indexing and Common Challenges

How to Design Customizable Data Indexing Pipelines

Star my work on github

Read My Stories

Too Long; Didn't Read

Make resilience your competitive advantage

How to Process Large Files in Data Indexing Systems

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

Untitled Story

Streamline Structured + Unstructured Data Flows from Postgres with AI

Data Indexing and Common Challenges

Keep Your Indexes Fresh With This Real-time Pipeline

Getting Started with Data Analytics in Python Using PyArrow

All About Parquet Part 02 - Parquet's Columnar Storage Model

Streamline Structured + Unstructured Data Flows from Postgres with AI

Data Indexing and Common Challenges

Keep Your Indexes Fresh With This Real-time Pipeline

Getting Started with Data Analytics in Python Using PyArrow

All About Parquet Part 02 - Parquet's Columnar Storage Model

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps