Bitcoin’s ETF is a double edged swordby@IggsLoop
1,204 reads
1,204 reads

Bitcoin’s ETF is a double edged sword

by Igor FeererJuly 16th, 2018
Read on Terminal Reader
Read this story w/o Javascript
tldt arrow

Too Long; Didn't Read

The current regulatory headwinds suggest that Bitcoin’s ETF will become an approved asset class and will come online soon. It will certainly drive the currency’s price through the roof. However, is this what Satoshi envisioned for his creation?

Companies Mentioned

Mention Thumbnail
Mention Thumbnail

Coin Mentioned

Mention Thumbnail
featured image - Bitcoin’s ETF is a double edged sword
Igor Feerer HackerNoon profile picture

The current regulatory headwinds suggest that Bitcoin’s ETF will become an approved asset class and will come online soon. It will certainly drive the currency’s price through the roof. However, is this what Satoshi envisioned for his creation?

Satoshi’s dream and our current reality are at an impasse. Satoshi wanted bitcoin to become the dominant e-currency the world over and at the rate that we are going, it is becoming highly probable that this dream has to overcome some traditional challenges.

Let’s first cover some basics.

The first line of Bitcoins white paper makes it very clear that bitcoin is to be used as a medium of exchange and for some a store of value.

A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution. — Satoshi

With that said, Satoshi dealt with the same problems that we are all subject to, namely the “missing variable problem.”

Missing variables are things that either don’t occur to us or are simply things that we have to leave for fate to decide. In Satoshi’s case, I argue that he couldn’t have assigned such a high probability to Bitcoins success in the first place, much less it’s ultimate commoditization by big financial institutions.

What will the Bitcoin ETF bring?

ETF’s are big business and as of last year their market size was $3 trillion doll hairs. Their success mainly embodies ease of use, low trading fees and can be advantageous to tax weary investors.

The interest in an ETF developing amongst crypto enthusiasts can be assigned in large part to greed. I am not calling you greedy, but the premise is that ETFs will have a major impact on the price of BTC and will inadvertently make it a store of value rather than it’s original vision aka a medium of exchange.

BTC ETF will drive the price to the moon (Shameless plug for a crowd sourced prediction engine.)

Bitcoin is capped at 21M total circulating supply. Right now there are 17.2 million mined coins. With 4M BTC lost or dormant, we really only have 13.2M available to trade. One other wrinkle is the Hodlers.

A recent survey of those already invested in bitcoin as of November of 2017 revealed that 40% are going to hodl between 1 and 3 years, while 44% plan on Hodling for longer than 4 years.

With supply being already low and demand rising, any economist can predict that BTC’s price is going to sky rocket. Yes I know this is a good thing for most of the Hodlers but it’s hard to see how BTC will be used as a medium of exchange.

The Bitcoin ETF consequences on Satoshi’s vission

ETFs are not bitcoin:

We are already short on bitcoin supply (given the lost tokens and ones that are being Hodled.

I’ve mentioned that making BTC ETF will drive the price up and while I cannot be upset with that notion (because I stand to increase my crypto portfolio), I can say that it will have an impact on bitcoin becoming a medium of exchange.

First the basics

When you buy an ETF, what you are actually doing is purchasing shares of a portfolio, which is designed to track the yield and return of its benchmark index. In this case, the portfolio company will acquire bitcoin and sell you a percent of their overall holdings.

In other words, you do not own the actual bitcoin and therefor cannot spend what you do not have. This is just one risk of buying an BTC ETF.

There are two other risks to briefly explain before you buy some BTC ETFs and not spend bitcoin the way that it was intended (I am sorry for the snarkyness).

  • The counter party risk — If one of the parties involved in the scheme (i.e. sourcing the bitcoin for the portfolio manager) fails to deliver, the ETF will be out of balance and not in parity with the market rate. In other words, you are dependent upon management prowess, fund structure, chain of custody, operational integrity, regulatory oversight, and delivery protocols.
  • The shaky bitcoin ecosystem — Custodians and sub-custodians, typically banks, are responsible for sourcing and storing the physical bitcoin associated with a BTC ETF. The question is, can custodian banks be trusted to 1) last as long as the Bitcoin in their vaults and 2) adequately safeguard their holdings?

What’s the recourse

BTC will undoubtably fork or we will have to rely on bitcoin cash as the medium of exchange because if BTC supply is locked up in institutional accounts and across the Hodlers, how can we build an economy that’s powered by crypto.

Word of Advice

Please consider the above points before buying into the hype. It’s not all that it is cracked up to be and while the price will sky rocket, ask yourself if this trajectory will bring Satoshi’s vision closer to reality or will bitcoin morph into something that Satoshi wouldn’t be able to recognize today? And, if you don’t care either way, at least buy the real Bitcoin.

I love you,


Find me on Twitter under @iggsloop

Igor is a lover and a fighter. He happens to enjoy shitposting on crypto twitter and getting a beer with friends. His latest venture seeks to help traders improve their ROI through a crowd driven price prediction platform, called KryptoLoop. The Wisdom of the Crowd model they use mitigates most of the biases traders contend with and distills their collective knowledge into a single price prediction. It’s the best sentiment indicator a crypto trader can find and their predictions are within a tiny margin of error from actual price.

A few other articles of mine that have gotten thousands of reads for you to check out:

What is so special about Tim Draper’s BTC $250K prediction?

Prediction markets are hot AF right now.