I still remember the morning our CTO walked into our weekly team meeting and dropped the bomb: "We're finally moving our databases to the cloud." After 8 years of babysitting our on-premise SQL Server infrastructure—the 2 AM alerts, the sweaty backup restoration drills, and those nerve-wracking version upgrades—I had mixed feelings. Part excitement, part dread, and a healthy dose of skepticism. It's been 14 months since we completed our migration to AWS RDS, and boy, do I have stories to tell. If you're considering a similar move, grab a coffee. This might save you some headaches. Show Me the Money: The Real Cost Story Let's cut to the chase—yes, we're saving money, but not exactly how we expected. The old way: Dropping $140K every 4-5 years on server refreshes, plus the joy of explaining to finance why we needed another storage expansion "urgently." Not to mention the electricity bills from our data center that seemed to only go in one direction: up. Now? We've chopped about 30% off our total database costs. But here's the kicker—our bill fluctuates month to month. Last quarter during our big product launch, usage spiked and so did our AWS bill. Our CFO called me asking if we'd been hacked! Had to explain that cloud bills reflect actual usage, not the "set it and forget it" hardware costs he was used to. Now he checks our CloudWatch dashboards more often than I do. Performance: When "Fast Enough" Isn't Anyone who says moving to RDS is always performance-neutral is selling you something. Our customer portal database? Smooth sailing from day one. Our analytics workload? A completely different story. Those complex queries that screamed on our tuned SQL Server suddenly felt like they were wading through molasses. Turns out our on-premise setup had local SSDs with ridiculous I/O throughput that the standard RDS configuration couldn't match. After a week of our analysts giving me the stink eye in the lunch room, I bit the bullet and upgraded to provisioned IOPS storage. Problem solved, but my carefully calculated cost savings took a hit. The most annoying part? Having to explain to developers why their local database queries ran differently in the cloud. I've become a broken record: "No, you can't just throw hardware at every performance problem in RDS." The Unexpected Freedom of Managed Services I won't lie—waking up and NOT seeing backup failure emails in my inbox still feels like a small miracle. Six months in, I realized I hadn't manually applied a single SQL Server patch or worried about a storage drive failing. My favorite moment? When our primary database instance had an issue at 3 AM, and the multi-AZ setup failed over automatically. The system kept running, and I only found out when I checked the event logs the next morning. I just sat there staring at my screen, wondering what to do with this strange new feeling called "peace of mind." Now my team actually works on things that move the business forward instead of babysitting infrastructure. Yesterday, we spent an entire day optimizing query performance for our sales team—work that kept getting pushed aside before when we were juggling server issues. The "You Can't Do That Anymore" Conversation Nobody tells you how many uncomfortable conversations you'll have after migrating: "No, we can't just RDP into the database server to run that quick fix script." "Sorry, but that custom monitoring agent you've used forever won't work in RDS." "Yes, I know SQL Server Agent used to handle that, but we need to rethink it now." The most painful one? Telling our senior DBA he couldn't use his beloved custom trace flags anymore. He looked at me like I'd stolen his dog. We ended up rebuilding his performance monitoring solution using CloudWatch and Lambda functions. It works better now, but man, those first few weeks were rough. Security: Better but Different Our security team initially freaked out about "putting our crown jewels in someone else's data center." The irony? Our security posture is actually stronger now. Remember our old way of handling database credential rotation? That manual quarterly process with the spreadsheet nobody wants to talk about? Gone. Replaced with AWS Secrets Manager and automated rotation. The compliance audit that used to take weeks of preparation? Last time, I just pulled AWS's certifications and documentation, mapped our controls, and was done in days instead of weeks. But here's what they don't tell you in the brochures: your security work doesn't disappear—it transforms. Instead of worrying about physical server access and OS patches, I'm now deep in IAM policies, VPC designs, and encryption settings. Different headaches, same aspirin. The New Superpowers: Automation and Flexibility The biggest win? The stuff we can do now that was practically impossible before. Last month, our product team needed a complete copy of production (sanitized, of course) for testing a major feature. In the old world, that would have meant capacity planning, hardware procurement, and weeks of delay. With RDS? I wrote a quick script that spun up a snapshot-based clone, ran our data sanitization routines, and handed them access credentials—all before lunch. They were genuinely shocked. Even better was watching our junior DBA's face when she created her first "infrastructure as code" template. She automated the entire database provisioning process, complete with parameter groups, security settings, and monitoring—all version-controlled in our Git repo. "This would have taken weeks to document and standardize before," she said. No kidding. The Migration Itself: Not for the Faint of Heart I won't sugarcoat it—migration was tough. We initially tried the AWS Database Migration Service (DMS), thinking it would work like magic. Spoiler: it didn't. We encountered character encoding problems, strange stored procedure translations, and performance bottlenecks. We ultimately adopted a hybrid approach: DMS for the initial heavy lifting, SQL Server native tools for validation, and custom scripts to manage the edge cases. Despite months of planning, our first production cutover still ran 4 hours behind schedule. I felt like I aged years that weekend. The strangest issue? A third-party application that relied on SQL Server's exact behavior around identity columns. It worked fine in testing but fell apart in production. We spent two days tracking that one down. My advice: Double your estimated migration timeline, then add weekends. And have a solid rollback plan—not just technically, but also make sure everyone knows when you'll make the call to trigger it. When RDS Makes Sense (And When It Doesn't) After going through this with multiple databases, I've developed a pretty good sense for when RDS shines: Our customer database with its predictable workload and critical uptime requirements? Perfect for RDS. The multi-AZ setup alone justified the migration. Our massive data warehouse with specialized performance tuning and custom agent requirements? We actually moved that one back on-premise after a failed RDS migration attempt. Some workloads just don't fit the managed service model. The development databases that teams spin up and down constantly? RDS is a dream for those. Developers create what they need, when they need it, without IT becoming a bottleneck. The Messy Reality (Conclusion) Fourteen months in, and I still occasionally miss some aspects of having complete control over our database servers. But would I return? Not a chance. The night our cooling system failed in the old server room, I received a text from my former colleague who still manages some on-premises systems. While he rushed to the office at midnight, I was watching Netflix. That pretty much sums it up. The move to RDS wasn't just a technical change—it fundamentally shifted how our team operates. We're more proactive, more developer-focused, and frankly, less stressed. We're building skills in automation and cloud architecture instead of hardware troubleshooting. It wasn't perfect, it wasn't always smooth, and it definitely wasn't as simple as AWS's marketing suggests. But for us, for most of our workloads, it was absolutely the right move. I still remember the morning our CTO walked into our weekly team meeting and dropped the bomb: "We're finally moving our databases to the cloud." After 8 years of babysitting our on-premise SQL Server infrastructure—the 2 AM alerts, the sweaty backup restoration drills, and those nerve-wracking version upgrades—I had mixed feelings. Part excitement, part dread, and a healthy dose of skepticism. It's been 14 months since we completed our migration to AWS RDS, and boy, do I have stories to tell. If you're considering a similar move, grab a coffee. This might save you some headaches. Show Me the Money: The Real Cost Story Let's cut to the chase—yes, we're saving money, but not exactly how we expected. The old way: Dropping $140K every 4-5 years on server refreshes, plus the joy of explaining to finance why we needed another storage expansion "urgently." Not to mention the electricity bills from our data center that seemed to only go in one direction: up. The old way: Now? We've chopped about 30% off our total database costs. But here's the kicker—our bill fluctuates month to month. Last quarter during our big product launch, usage spiked and so did our AWS bill. Our CFO called me asking if we'd been hacked! Had to explain that cloud bills reflect actual usage, not the "set it and forget it" hardware costs he was used to. Now he checks our CloudWatch dashboards more often than I do. Performance: When "Fast Enough" Isn't Anyone who says moving to RDS is always performance-neutral is selling you something. Our customer portal database? Smooth sailing from day one. Our analytics workload? A completely different story. Those complex queries that screamed on our tuned SQL Server suddenly felt like they were wading through molasses. Turns out our on-premise setup had local SSDs with ridiculous I/O throughput that the standard RDS configuration couldn't match. After a week of our analysts giving me the stink eye in the lunch room, I bit the bullet and upgraded to provisioned IOPS storage. Problem solved, but my carefully calculated cost savings took a hit. The most annoying part? Having to explain to developers why their local database queries ran differently in the cloud. I've become a broken record: "No, you can't just throw hardware at every performance problem in RDS." The Unexpected Freedom of Managed Services I won't lie—waking up and NOT seeing backup failure emails in my inbox still feels like a small miracle. Six months in, I realized I hadn't manually applied a single SQL Server patch or worried about a storage drive failing. My favorite moment? When our primary database instance had an issue at 3 AM, and the multi-AZ setup failed over automatically. The system kept running, and I only found out when I checked the event logs the next morning. I just sat there staring at my screen, wondering what to do with this strange new feeling called "peace of mind." Now my team actually works on things that move the business forward instead of babysitting infrastructure. Yesterday, we spent an entire day optimizing query performance for our sales team—work that kept getting pushed aside before when we were juggling server issues. The "You Can't Do That Anymore" Conversation Nobody tells you how many uncomfortable conversations you'll have after migrating: "No, we can't just RDP into the database server to run that quick fix script." "Sorry, but that custom monitoring agent you've used forever won't work in RDS." "Yes, I know SQL Server Agent used to handle that, but we need to rethink it now." The most painful one? Telling our senior DBA he couldn't use his beloved custom trace flags anymore. He looked at me like I'd stolen his dog. We ended up rebuilding his performance monitoring solution using CloudWatch and Lambda functions. It works better now, but man, those first few weeks were rough. Security: Better but Different Our security team initially freaked out about "putting our crown jewels in someone else's data center." The irony? Our security posture is actually stronger now. Remember our old way of handling database credential rotation? That manual quarterly process with the spreadsheet nobody wants to talk about? Gone. Replaced with AWS Secrets Manager and automated rotation. The compliance audit that used to take weeks of preparation? Last time, I just pulled AWS's certifications and documentation, mapped our controls, and was done in days instead of weeks. But here's what they don't tell you in the brochures: your security work doesn't disappear—it transforms. Instead of worrying about physical server access and OS patches, I'm now deep in IAM policies, VPC designs, and encryption settings. Different headaches, same aspirin. The New Superpowers: Automation and Flexibility The biggest win? The stuff we can do now that was practically impossible before. Last month, our product team needed a complete copy of production (sanitized, of course) for testing a major feature. In the old world, that would have meant capacity planning, hardware procurement, and weeks of delay. With RDS? I wrote a quick script that spun up a snapshot-based clone, ran our data sanitization routines, and handed them access credentials—all before lunch. They were genuinely shocked. Even better was watching our junior DBA's face when she created her first "infrastructure as code" template. She automated the entire database provisioning process, complete with parameter groups, security settings, and monitoring—all version-controlled in our Git repo. "This would have taken weeks to document and standardize before," she said. No kidding. The Migration Itself: Not for the Faint of Heart I won't sugarcoat it—migration was tough. We initially tried the AWS Database Migration Service (DMS), thinking it would work like magic. Spoiler: it didn't. We encountered character encoding problems, strange stored procedure translations, and performance bottlenecks. We ultimately adopted a hybrid approach: DMS for the initial heavy lifting, SQL Server native tools for validation, and custom scripts to manage the edge cases. Despite months of planning, our first production cutover still ran 4 hours behind schedule. I felt like I aged years that weekend. The strangest issue? A third-party application that relied on SQL Server's exact behavior around identity columns. It worked fine in testing but fell apart in production. We spent two days tracking that one down. My advice: Double your estimated migration timeline, then add weekends. And have a solid rollback plan—not just technically, but also make sure everyone knows when you'll make the call to trigger it. When RDS Makes Sense (And When It Doesn't) After going through this with multiple databases, I've developed a pretty good sense for when RDS shines: Our customer database with its predictable workload and critical uptime requirements? Perfect for RDS. The multi-AZ setup alone justified the migration. Our massive data warehouse with specialized performance tuning and custom agent requirements? We actually moved that one back on-premise after a failed RDS migration attempt. Some workloads just don't fit the managed service model. The development databases that teams spin up and down constantly? RDS is a dream for those. Developers create what they need, when they need it, without IT becoming a bottleneck. The Messy Reality (Conclusion) Fourteen months in, and I still occasionally miss some aspects of having complete control over our database servers. But would I return? Not a chance. The night our cooling system failed in the old server room, I received a text from my former colleague who still manages some on-premises systems. While he rushed to the office at midnight, I was watching Netflix. That pretty much sums it up. The move to RDS wasn't just a technical change—it fundamentally shifted how our team operates. We're more proactive, more developer-focused, and frankly, less stressed. We're building skills in automation and cloud architecture instead of hardware troubleshooting. It wasn't perfect, it wasn't always smooth, and it definitely wasn't as simple as AWS's marketing suggests. But for us, for most of our workloads, it was absolutely the right move.

The is an opinion piece based on the author’s POV and does not necessarily reflect the views of HackerNoon.

Better

Even

Freedom

Netflix

SQL Server to AWS RDS Migration: The Good, the Bad, and Everything in Between

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

Untitled Story

Creating DB Links in Oracle AWS RDS: A Comprehensive Guide

An Intro to the 7 Rs of Cloud Migration Strategy

A Simple Guide to Optimize Cost on AWS

How to Find an AWS Migration Partner

The Complete Guide to Successful Cloud Migration: Strategies and Best Practices

Creating DB Links in Oracle AWS RDS: A Comprehensive Guide

An Intro to the 7 Rs of Cloud Migration Strategy

A Simple Guide to Optimize Cost on AWS

How to Find an AWS Migration Partner

The Complete Guide to Successful Cloud Migration: Strategies and Best Practices

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps