Reddit has over 50 million daily active users, making it one of the most engaged online communities in the world. For founders and marketers, it represents a goldmine of potential customers already discussing problems their products can solve. But Reddit is notoriously difficult to crack. Self-promotion is heavily policed, the community is skeptical of marketing, and one wrong move can get you permanently banned. I spent three months figuring out how to make Reddit work as a marketing channel for my desktop application. This article shares the concrete lessons I learned — including the mistakes that wasted my first month. Background and Context I'm a solo developer who built a research tool for Reddit data. When I launched, I had: Zero marketing budgetZero existing audienceA product whose target users are literally on Reddit Zero marketing budget Zero existing audience A product whose target users are literally on Reddit Reddit seemed like the obvious place to start. The reality was more complicated. Month 1: Following Conventional Advice (And Why It Failed) I started by following the most common Reddit marketing advice: Join relevant subreddits (r/SaaS, r/SideProject, r/Entrepreneur)Be genuinely helpful in discussionsBuild karma before any self-promotionShare "building in public" updates about my journey Join relevant subreddits (r/SaaS, r/SideProject, r/Entrepreneur) Be genuinely helpful in discussions Build karma before any self-promotion Share "building in public" updates about my journey The result after four weeks: Approximately 12 website visits. The approach wasn't working. The result after four weeks: Three Core Mistakes Mistake #1: Targeting High-Traffic Threads Mistake #1: Targeting High-Traffic Threads I was commenting on posts that already had 100+ comments. These threads are essentially graveyards for new contributions — your comment gets buried immediately, and no one sees it regardless of quality. Mistake #2: Inefficient Discovery Process Mistake #2: Inefficient Discovery Process I spent 30-40 minutes daily manually scrolling through subreddits looking for relevant threads. This is unsustainable for anyone running a business solo, and I was still missing most opportunities. Mistake #3: Corporate-Sounding Communication Mistake #3: Corporate-Sounding Communication My comments were too polished. They read like a marketing professional wrote them — which immediately triggers skepticism in Reddit's community. Phrases like "Here are 7 tips to optimize your workflow" are red flags that signal promotional intent. The Turning Point: Two Key Realizations Around week five, I made two changes that transformed my results. Realization #1: Target Low-Competition Threads Posts with 0-5 comments are the highest-value opportunities on Reddit. Here's why: Visibility: Your comment will actually be readPositioning: Early comments tend to stay near the topTiming: If the thread gains traction later, you're already there Visibility: Your comment will actually be read Visibility: Positioning: Early comments tend to stay near the top Positioning: Timing: If the thread gains traction later, you're already there Timing: The challenge is finding these threads efficiently. Manually scrolling through multiple subreddits takes too long and misses most opportunities. I started using Reddit Toolbox, a desktop application I originally built for my own research, to batch-filter posts by comment count across multiple subreddits simultaneously. This reduced my discovery time from 40 minutes to roughly 10 minutes. Reddit Toolbox Realization #2: Write Like a Real Person Reddit's community has developed a strong sensitivity to marketing language. The solution is counter-intuitive: write worse. Specifically: Use shorter, less structured sentencesInclude casual language and occasional humorAdmit uncertainty and share failuresAvoid listicles and "tips" formatting Use shorter, less structured sentences Include casual language and occasional humor Admit uncertainty and share failures Avoid listicles and "tips" formatting Before (ineffective): Before (ineffective): "I'd recommend implementing a systematic approach to Reddit engagement, focusing on high-value communities and consistent value delivery." After (effective): After (effective): "yeah tried that last week — worked okay for r/SaaS but flopped completely in r/startups, not sure why" The second version sounds like a regular Reddit user. That's the point. Results After Three Months After implementing these changes, here are my current metrics: MetricValuePercentage of signups from Reddit~20%Daily time investment30 minutesDays per week5Best single day15 signupsWorst single day0 MetricValuePercentage of signups from Reddit~20%Daily time investment30 minutesDays per week5Best single day15 signupsWorst single day0 MetricValuePercentage of signups from Reddit~20%Daily time investment30 minutesDays per week5Best single day15 signupsWorst single day0 MetricValue Metric Value Percentage of signups from Reddit~20% Percentage of signups from Reddit ~20% Daily time investment30 minutes Daily time investment 30 minutes Days per week5 Days per week 5 Best single day15 signups Best single day 15 signups Worst single day0 Worst single day 0 Reddit is not my largest acquisition channel, but it's among the most consistent. More importantly, users acquired from Reddit show significantly higher engagement than users from other sources — likely because they already participate in communities relevant to my product. Practical Recommendations Based on three months of experimentation, here are specific recommendations for founders considering Reddit as a marketing channel: Target posts with 0-5 comments. Ignore popular threads entirely — they're not worth your time.Batch your research. Don't scroll endlessly. Use filtering tools to identify opportunities quickly, then engage strategically.Write conversationally. Drop the marketing voice. Be imperfect. Admit when you don't know things.Be patient. Reddit is not a quick-win channel. Expect minimal results in the first month while you learn the community dynamics.Know your niche. Reddit works best for founders who genuinely understand the communities they're engaging with. Authenticity is difficult to fake. Target posts with 0-5 comments. Ignore popular threads entirely — they're not worth your time. Target posts with 0-5 comments. Batch your research. Don't scroll endlessly. Use filtering tools to identify opportunities quickly, then engage strategically. Batch your research. Write conversationally. Drop the marketing voice. Be imperfect. Admit when you don't know things. Write conversationally. Be patient. Reddit is not a quick-win channel. Expect minimal results in the first month while you learn the community dynamics. Be patient. Know your niche. Reddit works best for founders who genuinely understand the communities they're engaging with. Authenticity is difficult to fake. Know your niche. Conclusion Reddit marketing isn't glamorous. Some days you'll get zero traction despite doing everything right. The growth is slow and requires consistent effort. But for solo founders targeting niche audiences, it offers something valuable: access to highly engaged potential users without requiring advertising budget. The users who discover you through genuine Reddit participation tend to be more engaged and more likely to convert. The key is approaching Reddit as a community member first and a marketer second. Target underserved threads, communicate authentically, and give it time to compound. Have you tried Reddit for marketing? I'd be interested to hear what approaches have worked for you in the comments. Have you tried Reddit for marketing? I'd be interested to hear what approaches have worked for you in the comments.

This story contains AI-generated text. The author has used AI either for research, to generate outlines, or write the text itself. 

Reddit Marketing for Solo Founders: A 3-Month Retrospective

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

My "Serverless" Dream Turned into an IP Ban Nightmare: Why I Moved to Desktop

10+ Reasons Why Outsourcing Software Development Fails

10 Myths Stopping You From Becoming an Entrepreneur

11 Lessons I Learned as a Tech Founder

114 Stories To Learn About Founder Advice

12 Product Design Principles While Working in Small Startups

My "Serverless" Dream Turned into an IP Ban Nightmare: Why I Moved to Desktop

10+ Reasons Why Outsourcing Software Development Fails

10 Myths Stopping You From Becoming an Entrepreneur

11 Lessons I Learned as a Tech Founder

114 Stories To Learn About Founder Advice

12 Product Design Principles While Working in Small Startups

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Minty

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps