Key Considerations for Structuring a Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO)

Decentralized Autonomous Organizations, or DAOs, have become a popular way of managing projects and communities. Simply put, a DAO is a digital organization that operates based on smart contracts. Decisions are made by members of the organization according to the model’s structure.

While the concept of a DAO is straightforward and may seem like the ideal type of organization for a crypto project, managing it is not easy.

In this article, we will discuss the key stages that the project team should take into account when choosing the DAO organizational structure.

The first stage is to define the goals and management structure of the DAO

The first thing to consider when creating a DAO is its goals and objectives. A DAO can be created for various reasons such as fundraising, investments, asset management, and more. The project team develops a structure, management mechanisms, and decision-making processes depending on the organization's tasks.

The management structure in a DAO can be democratic, meritocratic, or a combination of both. A democratic management structure means that each participant has an equal vote in decision-making. For example, if 100 people participate in a DAO, each has one vote for any decision.

In a meritocratic management structure, participants with a larger number of tokens have more weight in decision-making. If 100 people are participating in a DAO and one participant owns 50% of the tokens, their vote will carry more weight than any other participant's vote.

A combination of democratic and meritocratic structures is also possible. For example, a rule could be established where each participant has one vote, but participants with more tokens are granted an additional vote.

Aragon Network is an example of a democratic management structure in a DAO, while MakerDAO is an example of a meritocratic management structure.

Depending on a DAO's specific circumstances and goals, one governance structure may be more effective and fair than another.

For example, a meritocratic structure may be useful in cases where DAO participants want to reward those who make a greater contribution to the project's development. However, a meritocratic structure leads to the concentration of power and resources in the hands of a small group of participants, which may contradict the ideas of decentralization and equality that underlie any DAO.

The second stage is to choose the type of membership that suits the DAO's goals

DAOs can have two types of membership: open and closed. Open membership means that anyone can join the DAO and access its functions, such as voting on decisions. An example can be a DAO that develops open-source software.

Closed membership means that the DAO has certain criteria for joining, such as level of education, work experience, or financial capability. An example can be a DAO that invests in startups and requires members to have a certain level of participation.

Some examples of DAOs with closed membership:

• MetaCartel Ventures invests in early-stage projects on the Ethereum blockchain. To join the DAO, one must receive an invitation from current members or go through an approval process.

• The LAO invests in blockchain and cryptocurrency startups. To join the DAO, one must fill out an application and receive approval from current members.

• Flamingo DAO invests in NFT collections and infrastructure. New members must purchase a certain amount of tokens called FLM and receive approval from other members of the organization.

To determine which type of membership is suitable for a DAO, one needs to look at the goals of the organization. Open membership is suitable for projects where it is important to attract the maximum number of participants for the functioning of society. Closed membership is suitable for DAOs where it is important to attract qualified and experienced participants who must contribute to the development of the project.

The third stage is to determine the future tokenomics of the project

In simple terms, tokenomics refers to the token economy of a DAO. Tokens can be used for voting rights, staking, or as a means of exchange. When choosing a tokenomics strategy, the following aspects should be considered: how tokens are distributed among participants, how votes are managed, what privileges token holders have, how mining or token issuance occurs, and so on.

Here are some possible uses of tokens in a DAO:

• Utility tokens are used to pay for products or services provided by the DAO. They can also be used to pay fees or other charges within the organization or blockchain.

• Security tokens — digital equivalents of securities, such as stocks or bonds. With these tokens, investors receive dividends and can participate in voting on important decisions within the community.

• Voting tokens are used to vote on decisions related to DAO management. Each token can represent one vote. As we mentioned earlier, in some types of DAOs, the more tokens an investor has, the more influence they have on decisions.

• Governance tokens — with these tokens, investors can vote on changes to DAO rules or the appointment of new managers.

• Stablecoins — tokens that are tied to fiat currencies or other stable assets such as gold. These tokens allow investors to store their funds in a stable currency and use them to purchase goods and services within the DAO.

This is an incomplete list of token types in a DAO. It is not necessary to create a separate token for each use case - one token that combines several functions is sufficient.

Risks and Challenges of Creating and Managing a DAO

Creating your own DAO on the blockchain can have many benefits such as increased transparency, efficiency, reduced costs, and more.

However, like any project on the blockchain, it can also have its risks that need to be considered.

Security. A DAO can be the target of attacks by hackers, scammers, and other malicious actors. This can lead to fund theft, smart contract destruction, or other problems that can damage the reputation of the DAO and its participants. To secure the organization from attacks, reliable infrastructure and a team of experienced and competent developers will be required.

Regulatory Issues. Blockchain and cryptocurrencies still operate in the grey area in many countries. In some jurisdictions, DAO activity may fall under certain regulatory requirements, which can lead to prohibitions, fines, or other negative consequences. It is necessary to carefully study the legal environment and obtain legal advice to reduce risks.

Weak Governance Structure. A DAO does not have centralized management, which sometimes creates problems in decision-making and resolving conflicts between participants. If members of the community do not trust each other and drag out votes on important organizational issues, this will harm the efficiency and success of the DAO.

Issues with Financing and Tokenomics. Ineffective tokenomics can lead to problems. Price volatility, low liquidity, voting centralization, lack of incentives for community members - if the DAO tokenomics are not well thought out, it can lead to project failure.

Market and Price Risks. The cryptocurrency market is usually unstable and unpredictable. The value of the DAO token can fluctuate, which can affect the ability of the DAO to operate and achieve its goals. In addition, DAOs are vulnerable to market manipulation and price speculation, which can lead to financial losses for the DAO and its members.

Basic Rules for Creating an Effective DAO

DAO is a unique form of organization that allows members to make joint decisions and manage projects without intermediaries or centralized authorities. However, creating and managing a DAO is associated with significant risks related to the security and reliability of the technological infrastructure, as well as the possibility of manipulation and hacker attacks.

To avoid these risks, it is necessary to carefully consider every stage of creating and managing a DAO. This includes choosing a reliable blockchain platform, defining a management structure, and planning the project's tokenomics. It is also important to ensure a high level of security and reliability, using advanced technologies and algorithms, and regularly conducting audits and checks.

Managing a DAO can be a promising and effective solution for many projects and organizations, but only with the right approach and careful work on security and reliability.

Featured image source