Table of Links Abstract and 1. Introduction Diffraction Limit Comparisons for Future Telescopes
Photobombing in our Solar System
Consequences for Obtained Spectra
Mitigation Strategies and Discussion, and References 4. CONSEQUENCES FOR OBTAINED SPECTRA The possibility of Exo-Earth PSF contamination by other bodies necessitates understanding of the potential effect on obtained spectra. We extend our Earth as an exoplanet analogue to probe this effect by simulating photobombing spectra scenarios using the Planetary Spectrum Generator (PSG) (Villanueva et al. 2018). We simulated spectra of the inner solar system planets and Moon as observed by a 6m space telescope using a telescope/instrument configuration similar to the LUVOIR ECLIPS mode. We adapted models and observing parameters from Checlair et al. (2021) to simulate spectra of the system as viewed edge on (system inclination = 90◦ ) from 10 parsecs away with the planets at quadrature. Sampling techniques and radiative transfer details are given in Saxena et al. (2021) and observation geometry, planet, and instrument properties are in config files (see supplemental). Simulated planet spectra assumed a 1000 second maximum exposure time based on current and planned missions’ attempts to minimize impact of cosmic ray interference (Poberezhskiy et al. 2021; Giardino et al. 2019). Total observation time was set to be equal for all planets to probe the photobombing effects and set to 1000 hours, the approximate time required to distinguish key features in the Earth’s visible spectra to ≈ 5σ. This is also the approximate time of a single continuous starshade observability window assumed for the HabEx mission (Gaudi et al. 2020) and roughly half the time of the x-axis spacing in figure 2. Results are in figure 3 for the visible/near-infrared (left/right) wavelength ranges of ECLIPS. We plot individual planet spectra and spectra (with noise) of Earth alone and the Earth with three other photobombing scenarios in the visible, and Earth spectra (with noise) and two other photobombing scenarios for the near-infrared. The most notable feature of photobombing scenarios in the visible (Earth + Moon, Earth + Mars and Earth + Mars + Moon) is that in each case the additional source in the PSF results in additional flux and/or noise that complicates interpretation of spectra with respect to extricating molecular signatures. In the Earth + Moon scenario, overall continuum flux level is barely changed relative to the Earth only case, but oxygen feature depth is reduced and there is an increase in noise that reduces the significance of multiple features. In other visible spectra photobombing scenarios, the continuum flux and noise goes up significantly. While this reduces significance of some molecular features, there is also an additional spurious increase in the oxygen signature absorption depth, which may result in an erroneously interpreted greater oxygen abundance. In the infrared spectra, photobombing cases have some minor effects on continuum and molecular signature flux (with the Earth + Mars case having larger effects), but the greatest effect is significant increase in noise. This increase reduces the significance of molecular signatures (particularly in the Earth + Mars case) such that robust detection may not be possible in such observing scenarios. Note these simplified scenarios provide a snapshot of effects on spectra, without phase and inclination effects taken into account, and no consideration of other factors that may cause time varying spectra. They are also dependent on observational assumptions listed above. Author:
(1) Prabal Saxena, CRESST II/University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA and NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Maryland 20771, USA (prabal.saxena@nasa.gov). This paper is available on arxiv under ATTRIBUTION-SHAREALIKE 4.0 INTERNATIONAL license. Table of Links Abstract and 1. Introduction Abstract and 1. Introduction Diffraction Limit Comparisons for Future Telescopes Photobombing in our Solar System Consequences for Obtained Spectra Mitigation Strategies and Discussion, and References Diffraction Limit Comparisons for Future Telescopes Diffraction Limit Comparisons for Future Telescopes Photobombing in our Solar System Photobombing in our Solar System Consequences for Obtained Spectra Consequences for Obtained Spectra Mitigation Strategies and Discussion, and References Mitigation Strategies and Discussion, and References 4. CONSEQUENCES FOR OBTAINED SPECTRA The possibility of Exo-Earth PSF contamination by other bodies necessitates understanding of the potential effect on obtained spectra. We extend our Earth as an exoplanet analogue to probe this effect by simulating photobombing spectra scenarios using the Planetary Spectrum Generator (PSG) (Villanueva et al. 2018). We simulated spectra of the inner solar system planets and Moon as observed by a 6m space telescope using a telescope/instrument configuration similar to the LUVOIR ECLIPS mode. We adapted models and observing parameters from Checlair et al. (2021) to simulate spectra of the system as viewed edge on (system inclination = 90◦ ) from 10 parsecs away with the planets at quadrature. Sampling techniques and radiative transfer details are given in Saxena et al. (2021) and observation geometry, planet, and instrument properties are in config files (see supplemental). Simulated planet spectra assumed a 1000 second maximum exposure time based on current and planned missions’ attempts to minimize impact of cosmic ray interference (Poberezhskiy et al. 2021; Giardino et al. 2019). Total observation time was set to be equal for all planets to probe the photobombing effects and set to 1000 hours, the approximate time required to distinguish key features in the Earth’s visible spectra to ≈ 5σ. This is also the approximate time of a single continuous starshade observability window assumed for the HabEx mission (Gaudi et al. 2020) and roughly half the time of the x-axis spacing in figure 2. Results are in figure 3 for the visible/near-infrared (left/right) wavelength ranges of ECLIPS. We plot individual planet spectra and spectra (with noise) of Earth alone and the Earth with three other photobombing scenarios in the visible, and Earth spectra (with noise) and two other photobombing scenarios for the near-infrared. The most notable feature of photobombing scenarios in the visible (Earth + Moon, Earth + Mars and Earth + Mars + Moon) is that in each case the additional source in the PSF results in additional flux and/or noise that complicates interpretation of spectra with respect to extricating molecular signatures. In the Earth + Moon scenario, overall continuum flux level is barely changed relative to the Earth only case, but oxygen feature depth is reduced and there is an increase in noise that reduces the significance of multiple features. In other visible spectra photobombing scenarios, the continuum flux and noise goes up significantly. While this reduces significance of some molecular features, there is also an additional spurious increase in the oxygen signature absorption depth, which may result in an erroneously interpreted greater oxygen abundance. In the infrared spectra, photobombing cases have some minor effects on continuum and molecular signature flux (with the Earth + Mars case having larger effects), but the greatest effect is significant increase in noise. This increase reduces the significance of molecular signatures (particularly in the Earth + Mars case) such that robust detection may not be possible in such observing scenarios. Note these simplified scenarios provide a snapshot of effects on spectra, without phase and inclination effects taken into account, and no consideration of other factors that may cause time varying spectra. They are also dependent on observational assumptions listed above. Author: (1) Prabal Saxena, CRESST II/University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA and NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Maryland 20771, USA (prabal.saxena@nasa.gov). Author: Author: (1) Prabal Saxena, CRESST II/University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA and NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Maryland 20771, USA (prabal.saxena@nasa.gov). This paper is available on arxiv under ATTRIBUTION-SHAREALIKE 4.0 INTERNATIONAL license. This paper is available on arxiv under ATTRIBUTION-SHAREALIKE 4.0 INTERNATIONAL license. available on arxiv available on arxiv

Part of HackerNoon's growing list of open-source research papers, promoting free access to academic material.

How Nearby Planets Impact the Spectra of Earth-like Exoplanets

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

Untitled Story

How Other Planets and Their Moons Sabotage Our Search for Earth Twins

Space Telescopes Might Be Seeing More Than They Bargained For

How Other Planets and Their Moons Sabotage Our Search for Earth Twins

How Planets 'Photobomb' Earth's View in Space Telescope Observations

Mitigating the Effects of Photobombing in Exoplanet Observations

How Other Planets and Their Moons Sabotage Our Search for Earth Twins

Space Telescopes Might Be Seeing More Than They Bargained For

How Other Planets and Their Moons Sabotage Our Search for Earth Twins

How Planets 'Photobomb' Earth's View in Space Telescope Observations

Mitigating the Effects of Photobombing in Exoplanet Observations

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps